If this email is not displayed correctly, please click here to view in a web browser.
September Issue of the Republican Roundup
May 2005

Chair's Report
Common Cause - an Alliance of Commonwealth Republican Movements
ARM Speeches and Articles
ARM Media Releases
News
ARM Membership renewals
What's On

Welcome to Republican Roundup, the monthly e-newsletter of the Australian Republican Movement.



Chair's report

April was a somewhat quieter month, after February and March were full on. But there are still a number of things to report, including important developments at the State level, the launch of Common Cause with the three other Commonwealth republican movements joining ARM, media coverage of the wedding of Charles and Camilla, a pro-republic speech by Senator Amanda Vanstone, and the revelation that the Queen's approval had to be sought for alterations necessary for medals to be awarded to the servicemen and women who died in the Indonesian helicopter crash.

In my article Republic not just a state of the nation, but a matter for the states in the Canberra Times on 15 April, I discussed republican developments at the state level. The most current of these are changes to the oaths of allegiance being considered by the NSW and WA parliaments. Other states are also dabbling in the issue. These bills remove reference to the Queen. They are part of a general republican trend to remove prefixes such as "Royal", "Crown", and "Queen's" in the public and private sector. We should welcome these developments and support them whenever possible. Our opponents have very few weapons with which to attack non-constitutional republicanism. They sneer at "creeping republicanism" because they have no arguments. What is happening is open and public change driven by the republican spirit of our nation.

Look out for a forthcoming major article in the Australian Journal of International Affairs by Richard Woolcott, who delivered the 2003 National Republican Lecture. He sent the ARM a copy and rang to emphasise his continuing support. Richard writes: "The establishment of an Australian Republic is not only a Constitutional issue. It is also has important foreign and trade implications in that the fact that Queen Elizabeth is our Head of State is confusing to many other countries. The 1999 Referendum was a tragic lost opportunity to redefine Australia to the world. Our constitutional arrangements and our symbols should reflect what we aspire to be, not what we were." He concludes: "I have no doubt, on the basis of representing Australia for 40 years, that the earliest possible establishment of the Australian Republic will serve both Australia's domestic and international interests."

After months of discussions, in which ARM was represented by our National Director Allison Henry, we launched Common Cause earlier this month with a media release. Common Cause is an agreement between the republican movements of Australia, Britain, New Zealand and Canada to work together where it is useful, while still maintaining our independent objectives. We will exchange information and ideas and issue joint media releases on matters of common concern. Where there is no agreement there will be no common action. The whole idea is to help one another on the grounds that we all benefit as each individual movement becomes stronger. I would like to especially recognise the leading role that our ND has played in this development.

The Royal wedding maintained our profile through the first week of April. We distributed a media release and took every opportunity to emphasise that this was a wake up call to Australians that Charles will become our future head of state unless we change our constitution and become a republic.

About the same time I received a response, dated 22nd March, from Clarence House to our letter delivered to Charles while he was staying at Government House, Yarralumla. James Kidner, Assistant Private Secretary wrote: "The Prince of Wales has asked me to thank you for your kind letter of 4th March, and to say how much he enjoyed meeting representatives of your movement while he was in Australia [That didn't happen, of course!]. It was good of you to take the trouble to write, and His Royal Highness well understands the sentiments you expressed in the letter, which could not have been expressed more courteously". Charles has extended to ARM greater courtesy than we have so far been extended by the Governor-General. We have made this comparison to the media.

Immigration Minister, Senator Amanda Vanstone, devoted her Sir Thomas Playford Memorial Lecture at Adelaide University to her case for a minimalist republic. She has been a long-standing and consistent republican and I applaud her for that. When asked by the media to comment on her speech I agreed with two of Senator Vanstone's themes. The first is that republican unity is essential for us to win a referendum and the second is that republican campaigns should be positive rather than unduly negative. I disagree with Amanda on some details but I like her republican slogan for monarchists: "If you love her, set her free."

The need for Royal approval for changes to Australian medals gives the lie to monarchist claims that the Queen has no practical role in Australian politics. We got a good run on ABC's PM program to make this point. When the opportunity arises we will make this general point again. The claims of the monarchists that the Queen has disappeared from Australian life for all practical purposes are just not true.

Best wishes
John Warhurst, ARM Chair

Back to top


On 7 April 2005 the ARM joined with Citizens for a Canadian Republic (CCR), the Republican Movement of Aotearoa New Zealand (RMANZ) and Republic in the UK in launching Common Cause, an alliance of Commonwealth republican movements.

Reflecting their distinctive political and constitutional circumstances, each of the organizations in Common Cause will retain their autonomous national campaigns while sharing information, resources and ideas to bring about their common goal.

While currently limited to republican organisations in Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United Kingdom, Common Cause is open to any republican movement within the Commonwealth sharing its aims.

Common Cause is an exciting development for the republican movements in each of our countries, demonstrating that the campaign for democratic Heads of State is no longer just an Australian issue: many countries in the Commonwealth are questioning the future of the monarchy.

Back to top
ARM Speeches and Articles

15 Apr 2005
Republic not just a state of the nation, but a matter for the states

Article by John Warhurst, Canberra Times

Back to top
ARM Media Releases

8 Apr 2005
Republicans wish royal couple well

Back to top
News

REPUBLICAN DEVELOPMENTS IN THE STATES
Following on from reforms last year to replace royal symbols and rename "Crown" Lands in NSW as "State" Lands the NSW Parliament has recently revisited the issue of MP's oath of allegiance.

The Constitution Amendment (Pledge of Loyalty) Bill seeks to amend the NSW Constitution so that Members of Parliament and Ministers take a pledge of loyalty to Australia and to the people of New South Wales instead of swearing allegiance to the Queen. The Bill passed the NSW Legislative Assembly on 7 April 2005 and is expected to shortly pass the Legislative Council.

7 April 2005
MPs transfer allegiance from Queen to constituents

ABC Online

6 April 2005
State MPs vote to dump oath to Queen

Jane Gibson, SMH

The WA Parliament, after considering legislation last year to reform WA oaths also recently reintroduced the Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Bill 2005. The Bill is currently being considered by the WA Legislative Council.

Our opponents oppose these reforms - Australians for Constitutional Monarchy Executive Director Kerry Jones last year argued that Changing the Oaths of Allegiance amounts to republicanism by stealth. But as ARM Chair John Warhurst argued in his article Republic not just a state of the nation, but a matter for the states, "Monarchists can't have it both ways. They allege that republicans are hypocritical when they swear allegiance to the Queen, yet they complain when changes are introduced to rectify the situation."


MEDALS APPROVED BY QUEEN
Following the tragic deaths of nine Australian military personnel in Nias, the Prime Minister announced that hundreds of Australian military personnel would be awarded the Humanitarian Overseas Service Medal. The Prime Minister's announcement made clear that the Queen had "provided in-principle approval for this medal", highlighting one of the many roles the Queen retains in Australia.

Monarchists of course insist that the Governor General is our Head of State. As we highlighted in last May's Republican Round Up - when medals for servicemen and women serving in Afghanistan and Iraq, and approved by the Queen, were announced - why should the approval of the Queen be sought if she is not our Head of State?

ARM Chair John Warhurst appeared on the ABC radio's PM program, arguing that "that this is just the sort of thing that an Australian head of state should be doing and it shouldn't involve the Queen at all."

12 April 2005
Queen's role in question over military awards

Jayne-Maree Sedgman, PM, ABC radio


MEDIA REPORTING
Regular readers of Republican Round Up would be aware that here at the ARM we like to keep a close eye on media reporting, particularly in relation to the whole question of who is Australia's head of state.

Two latest examples…

It seems the BBC was having trouble finding an Australian sufficiently interested in the marriage of Prince Charles and Camilla Parker Bowles and succumbed to interviewing Australian for Constitutional Monarchy chair Professor David Flint. Unfortunately the BBC didn't feel the need to disclose Professor Flint's position with ACM, as uncovered by the ABC's Media Watch program…

18 April 2005
The BBC's typical Aussie monarchist

Media Watch, ABC TV

Congratulations to the ARM's Victorian Convenor, Peter Van Vliet, who recently complained to the ABC following a news website report on March 3 that several thousand Melburnians had turned out to greet Prince Charles in the city centre. van Vliet argued that the report was "wildly inaccurate" and that no more than several hundred people had welcomed Prince Charles. After ABC corporate affairs initially maintained the report was accurate, van Vliet wrote to the ABC's Complaints Review Executive, who found there were reasons to question the accuracy of the ABC's report of the crowd number, including a lack of corroboration from other media. In his written determination, the ABC's Mr Batten said the complaint was justified, and recommended that clarification be made in an appropriate form. van Vliet is yet to be informed that the ABC has corrected the record…


GG'S PAST AND PRESENT IN THE NEWS

30 April 2005
Former G-G costs taxpayers $1600 a day

Simon Kearney & Kate Legge, The Australian

12 April 2005
Prince Charles lands himself in another diplomatic incident

Guy Adams, The Independent (UK)


REPUBLICAN SENATOR VANSTONE
Unfortunately Senator Vanstone's Sir Thomas Playford Memorial Lecture is not available online, however a recent transcript from ABC radio's Sunday Profile highlights her republican colours.

10 April 2005
Senator Amanda Vanstone

Sunday Profile, ABC radio

Back to top
ARM Membership renewals

It is again coming up to that time of the year when we ask if you could please renew your ARM membership.

For the first time since the 1999 referendum (and indeed since the introduction of the GST) we will this year be increasing our annual membership fees.

Standard membership will increase from $36 to $48 and Household membership from $48 to $60. Concession membership for pensioners and students remains at $12. We are also abolishing the pro-rata system so that these rates apply throughout the membership year (1 June - 31 May). Any new members joining from March-May will automatically receive 13-15 months membership for the annual fee.

The rate rise reflects increased administrative costs in running the ARM and we hope will reduce pressure on other income steams, most particularly branch fundraising.

Most financial members will have already received their renewal notices, the remainder will be sent out shortly. If you have previously given the ARM an authorisation for automatic deduction, it will be effected in the week beginning 16 May.

Renew your membership online

Back to top
What's On

MAY

SA Annual Republican Fundraising Dinner with Guest Speaker Bill Peach
Date: Friday 6 May 2005
Time: 7.00 for 7:30pm
Venue: West Adelaide Footballers Club
Address: 57 Milner Rd, Richmond
Cost: $45 per head ~ drinks at club prices
RSVP: Geoff 0417 086 768 or sa@republic.org.au
Flyer

ARM Vic State Council Meeting and Dinner in the Goldfields
Date: Saturday 14 May 2005
Time: SC Meeting – 5.30 to 6:30pm ~ Dinner 7.00pm
Venue: Shamrock Hotel
Address: Corner Pall Mall and Williamson Street, Bendigo
Drinks/Dinner at Restaurant Prices
RSVP: Simon Bateman, Vic Secretary, vic@republic.org.au
Flyer

Tasmanian Republican Gathering with ARM Chair John Warhurst
Date: Tuesday 24 May 2005
Time: 6.00pm - 7.30pm
Venue: The Republic Bar & Cafe (upstairs room)
Address: cnr Elizabeth and Burnett Streets. North Hobart
Cost: Gold coin donation ~ buy your own drinks at the bar upstairs (nibbles provided)
RSVP: Friday 20 May to Lisa Singh 0438 380 988
All welcome to stay on for dinner at the Republic after when there will be further opportunity to chat with John informally.
Flyer

JUNE

Victorian ARM Annual Conference
Date: Saturday 4 June 2005
Time: 9am - 1pm
Venue: Building Display Centre
Address: 332 Albert St, East Melbourne
Cost: $10/$5 conc
RSVP: vic@republic.org.au

followed by

Victorian Annual Fundraising Dinner, with special guest speaker Senator Natasha Stott Despoja
Date: Saturday 4 June 2005
Time: 7pm for 7.30pm
Venue: Republic Café and Bar
Address: 365 LaTrobe Street Melbourne
Cost: $55 / $45 conc
RSVP: vic@republic.org.au
Flyer

2005 ACT Annual Fundraising Dinner, with special guest speaker Senator Marise Payne
Date: Saturday 4 June 2005
Time: 7pm
Venue: The Sky Lounge and Terrace, Yamba Southern Cross Sports Club
Address: Irving Street, Phillip
Cost: $35 (three course meal ~ drinks at club prices)
RSVP: Jane Castles on 0412 392 577 or email act@republic.org.au
Flyer

ACT ARM BRANCH MEETING
Date: Monday 6 June 2005
Time: 7.45pm (Members are welcome to join others for a meal before the meeting at 6.30pm in the Italian Bistro)
Venue: Italo-Australian Club
Further details / RSVP: Jane Castles 0412 392 577 or act@republic.org.au

ARM Quarterly Fundraising Lunch with special guest John Bell
Hosted by the Hon Dr Meredith Burgmann MLC
Date: Wednesday 15 June 2005
Time: 12:15 for 12:30pm
Venue: President’s Dining Room, NSW Parliament House
Address: Macquarie Street, Sydney
Cost: $165 (includes three course meal and drinks)
RSVP: director@republic.org.au
Flyer

JULY

NSW State Council Annual Fundraising Lunch with special guest Ian Keirnan
Date: Friday 1 July 2005
Time: 12:30pm
Venue: Strangers Dining Room, NSW Parliament House
Address: Macquarie Street, Sydney
Cost: $100 (includes three course meal and drinks)
RSVP: nsw@republic.org.au
Flyer

ACT ARM BRANCH MEETING
Date: Monday 4 July 2005
Time: 7.45pm (Members are welcome to join others for a meal before the meeting at 6.30pm in the Italian Bistro)
Venue: Italo-Australian Club
Further details / RSVP: Jane Castles 0412 392 577 or act@republic.org.au

AUGUST

The ARM’s NSW Council presents a guided tour of the Margaret Preston Retrospective to be followed by drinks
Venue: The NSW Art Gallery
Address: Art Gallery Road Sydney
Date: 3 August 2005
Time: 5.30 pm
Cost: $20.00 per person
RSVP: nsw@republic.org.au
Flyer

ACT ARM BRANCH MEETING
Date: Monday 1 August 2005
Time: 7.45pm (Members are welcome to join others for a meal before the meeting at 6.30pm in the Italian Bistro)
Venue: Italo-Australian Club
Further details / RSVP: Jane Castles 0412 392 577 or act@republic.org.au

Back to top
Over 10,000 people receive Republican Roundup each month... but there's always room for more.

Please forward this email to friends and colleagues who support an Australian Head of State.

You have received this email because you are registered as an ARM member or supporter.
To unsubscribe, please click here.